Skip to main content

Can Landlords Choose Their Own Tenants? Here’s What You Need to Know

Can Landlords Choose Their Own Tenants? Here’s What You Need to Know

Many property owners ask: “How involved can I be in selecting my tenants?”

It’s a fair question and one that comes with important legal implications.


Where the Line Is and Why It Matters

“We have to follow our policies and procedures equally… We can’t approve one person and deny another without applying the same criteria.”

Tenant selection isn't about preferences; it’s about fairness and compliance. At RHOME, we adhere to well-defined screening policies that apply the same criteria to every applicant. This protects our clients from legal exposure and ensures we comply with federal fair housing laws.

The Role of HUD and Fair Housing Compliance

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) has strict guidelines that govern how rental applications are handled. This means:

  • All applicants must be evaluated using the same standards

  • Landlords cannot pick and choose tenants based on personal preferences

  • Any deviation from established policies can lead to legal consequences

“You’re walking a fine line, and we’re not willing to put you or ourselves in that liability.”

Why RHOME Follows a Standardized Process

We’ve built a compliant, consistent screening system to keep our clients protected and our tenant selection fair. It’s not about being hands-off; it’s about doing things the right way, every time.

RHOME’s approach:

  • Applies the same qualifications across all applicants

  • Keeps detailed records for accountability

  • Ensures clients stay protected from discrimination claims

Protecting Your Investment Starts with Compliance

Tenant screening is one of the most legally sensitive aspects of rental management. That’s why RHOME follows a proven process that protects both parties: landlords and residents alike.

Want to know how we screen tenants fairly and effectively?
Let’s talk about how RHOME can help you rent smarter—and safer.

back